There’s a flurry of …
[I was going to say excitement but it's a lot more passionate than that. Come to think of it, it's probably more than a flurry, too. Flurries in Chicago we can live with. It's the snow blowing sideways into huge drifts, the white-out conditions that aren't much fun. This is somewhere in between.]
As I was saying there’s an opinionated exchange going on over at the Chicago Writers Association forum.
It started innocently enough with a request for a critique partner. From there it blew up into entirely something else. On Saturday, Ed Toolis joined in.
This was his introduction:
I’m new here, so I don’t know my way around yet.
This is what I’ve done and what I’ve gone through. I’m and ex-business owner and I’ve been working on a humorous, battle of the sexes novel for around 14 years. I recently finished the 13th draft, I’m finally happy with the manuscript, and now I’m looking for an agent. (I’m also working on another novel, but it’ll be the end of the year before I even get a first draft.)
Now, I define a writer as someone who pours his or her heart and soul into a draft, sends it out for critique, gets told it’s crap, cries and swears for a day or two, then sits down and writes a list of impossible problems to solve, then gets to work solving them. And this is how I learned the craft, the structure of the novel and scenes, humor, and how to deal with the powerful negative emotions that come with this field.
I joined this group because I’m embarrassed that a world-class city like Chicago doesn’t seem to have hundreds of writing groups, all struggling and helping each other, in a conspiracy to kick literary ass. And because of this, I want to help anyone I can.
Personally, I didn’t think his remark about Chicago was inflammatory. Derogatory maybe. Others took exception and the discussion took off in several directions. [None of these, of course, became their own threads because CWAers aren't very savvy about forum use. Which is why you'll find so many disparate things included under the same heading. Don't let that stop you from joining ... you just need to make good use of the search function!]
Suddenly, at least it seemed so to me, Ed posted the following. It is reproduced with his permission. I thought it would serve as an interesting introduction to my series on Chicago-area writing groups.
So are we going to just whine . . . [Ed's header]
about not having a vibrant writing community here or are we going to do something about it, besides everyone getting an MFA? We’re Chicagoans, for crying out loud! We’re capable of anything we set our minds to. Chicago is a town where amazing things can happen. I know. I came here with nothing, which included anybody thinking I’d ever amount to anything, and I retired from the business I started with a fair amount of money. And if I can make it here, everybody can.
Let’s start by making a list, as if we’re going to write an article to go in the Writer’s Digest or something.. If there was a vibrant community here, what would it provide?
Let’s start with two types of writers. (1) A beginner who has gone through hell and has finished a first draft. (2) A writer who has written a lot but can’t seem to get accepted by a good agent.
Isn’t it out responsibility to help them, us? Do you think that (1) has the potential to be a great writer? This person needs the help you wish you had gotten, right? You remember what it felt like to make a list of all the things that needed to be done to turn your novel into something decent, saw that everything on the list was impossible for you to accomplish, and didn’t know where to turn, right? Don’t you feel obligated to make sure this person doesn’t finally give up, so that all those beautiful hopes and dreams become a waste? And (2). Do you really believe that all those lessons you’ve learned the hard way are of no use to anyone? That we all live in our own isolated worlds and can’t speed up each other’s development? In your heart, you have to believe that all novels have the potential for greatness; otherwise, you wouldn’t have been able to take yours as far as you did. Can you really live with yourself if you don’t do what you can to help this person take theirs to the next level?
Are you with me? Show of hands. Who’s got ideas to help these people? What other types need to be added to the outline of this “article?” Because I swear, if I don’t see the creativity that we’re all supposed to have, I’ll kill this cute little puppy.
[Note: do not panic. No actual puppy is being referred to. At least I don't think so.]